Will China Fail: The Limits and Contradictions of Market Socialism 2nd Edition

John LeeMay 28, 2009PM96

Debates about China have been overloaded by the burden of interests rather than investigation, by stiff and opinionated ideology rather than examination of the ‘engines’ of China’s economy and society. John Lee’s book breaks with these weaknesses by deftly and precisely examining the fundamental processes that shape China’s ‘economic miracle’ and the country’s modern evolution. As such, it is a landmark in China studies. It makes no claims but analyses, and as such ought to be taken with utmost seriousness by policy makers and academics.

Lee’s contention is that the PRC’s economy centers not on job creation as it occurs in true capitalist ‘creative destruction’ but on the mobilization of resources to preserve the tens of millions of jobs tied to the state-controlled sectors that provide sustenance to a large part of the ruling class and social base of the Chinese Communist Party. Many are inefficient cradle-to-grave social institutions, not enterprises.

Under circumstances of world recession, the People’s Republic of China’s fading miracle is more likely to fracture than not. It may well add fuel to the rise of malicious chauvinism. Much study is being devoted in Beijing and Shanghai to understand the causes and consequences of ongoing events; much sound advice is being proffered by high-level intellectual advisers. They crash against the real Wall of China—the unilateral claim to power of the power-holders. John Lee is to be highly commended for having demonstrated it in concrete fashion.

NOTE: HARD COPY IS OUT OF STOCK

Related Commentary

Religious tests a red line we shouldn’t cross
Peter KurtiJanuary 29, 2026DAILY TELEGRAPH
Morrison deserves credit for insisting accusations of Islamophobia must not shut down necessary debate. But...
It’s judgment day: time for unis to kick politics off campus
Steven SchwartzJanuary 29, 2026THE AUSTRALIAN
The problem is not academic freedom itself. The problem is that universities have forgotten what...
Fear after Bondi is putting free speech on trial
Peter KurtiJanuary 14, 2026AUSTRALIAN FINANCIAL REVIEW
Instead of rushing to add new laws to an already swollen statute book, we should...

• Subscribe

Subscribe now and stay in the loop with our giving appeals, event alerts, newsletters and research updates.

We are always pleased to hear from you. If you have any questions or feedback, please contact us here: